clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Toffees Mailbag: Everton vs the top six, Allardyce’s replacement, and Tosun

Answering all of your relevant (even though the team’s not), and irreverent (because you need it) Everton questions.

I’ll be honest.

These things are getting less and less fun to write by the week.


Well how about I let the fans tell remind you:

Put another way:




Now that we are all in a good mood, let’s get to your questions!

I’m willing you bet you aren’t the only person who is having that EXACT thought right now.

In fact, let’s take a quick vote.

Who feels the same way:

Come on now.....

That’s better.

Nope, you are certainly NOT alone in your wishes to balance non-relegation with being bad enough to get Big Sam canned.

In fact, anyone who DOESN’T have this mindset is from another planet or a member of the Allardyce family.

You know what, strike that last qualifier. I imagine even Big Sam’s closest relatives can’t stand to watch the disheveled mess the Toffees currently are. They probably long for the days when Sam Allardyce was taking bribes and kickbacks under the table.

They would say something like:

‘If you’re not cheating, you’re not trying!’

In that case Big Sam MUST be trying his hardest.

Because I don’t know about you, but I certainly feel cheated. You just know that if Big Sam was involved in the other football then he’d be part of the New England Patriots organization.

Everton General Meeting Photo by Tony McArdle/Everton FC via Getty Images

As for Steve Walsh, his removal may prove to be more of a difficult situation.

His appointment as Director of Football almost two years ago was one of new owner Farhad Moshiri’s efforts to revitalize the Toffees on the pitch.

The subsequent appoint of Ronald Koeman gave Moshiri the two-headed monster he so desired:

Walsh to recruit them, Koeman to manage them.

Of course Koeman was let go a few weeks into this season and the Toffees have endured a dreadful season.

If Moshiri were to let go of Walsh now it would be an admission of guilt that he got it doubly wrong and would have a feeling of ‘going back to the beginning’ about it.

However, what Moshiri HOPEFULLY understands is that while he has not felt the wrath of Toffees fans because his exhaustive financial efforts have set up the Toffees for the long-term, his failure to remove Walsh would show a stubbornness that would raise red flags.

Fans can deal with the new guy getting it wrong, but they CAN’T deal with him not being able to admit it.

Should Moshiri fail to act decisively as soon as (or even before) the end of the season, Everton fans may turn their anger all the way to the top and officially erode ANY good feelings between the front office and the fans.

Dear Everton,

.. and prove me right.

Cenk Tosun has shown nothing but hustle and hard work since he has arrived on the scene at Goodison.

After spending upwards of £27 million on the Turkish striker, it was assumed that he would have a run of games to settle into the squad and prove his worth.

Arsenal v Everton - Premier League Photo by Tony McArdle/Everton FC via Getty Images

After getting over 60 minutes each against Tottenham Hotspur and West Bromwich Albion (both losses), Tosun has since been sequestered on the bench minus a late cameo in Arsenal’s 5-1 thrashing of Everton this past weekend.

Big Sam has said that Tosun has needed time to adjust before he can start regularly (an argument undermined by his immediate insertion into the lineup), and that the English game has overwhelmed him.

Unfortunately for Sam, if this were the only metric to determine a player’s ability to start the hapless Toffees would be incapable of fielding a squad having been beaten soundly all season long.

So either Allardyce has a player who isn’t ready for the league and Walsh and Co. are to blame, or Allardyce is actively undermining the squad by benching a player who is obviously superior to the competition at his position.

Either way, the entire mess is just another symptom of a club that is incapable of executing a simple strategy.

I for one hope Tosun gets a handful of starts, and a few goals, before the end of the season so that when the next manager comes in the talented striker’s confidence hasn’t been completely eroded.

As always Everton..

I am going to continue to answer some version of this question in each mailbag, so I went ahead and made a graphic for my top two candidates (awkward pictures just because):

Both men have both built squads as well as taken over dominant teams and done well.

They give youth a chance and their players seem to like them for the most part.

Hopefully Farhad will take this into consideration when he reads the Toffees Mailbag.


Need Your Light

Ra Ra Riot

This is an absolutely energizing album.

Depressed about the Toffees?


Check out this album and I assure you that you will be on your feet dancing in no time!

You will still be crying....