clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Everton at Manchester United: Writer Prediction League

New, comment

The Toffees usually struggle away to the big six — can they turn things around at Old Trafford?

Manchester United v Wolverhampton Wanderers - Premier League Photo by Matthew Lewis/Getty Images

Three straight league wins for Everton has the Toffees right back where they want to be — even after a slow start to the season.

Last weekend’s victory over Crystal Palace put the club into eighth place in the Premier League, just two points behind Bournemouth for sixth place, the highest spot the Toffees can feasibly hope to attain this season.

That race for sixth place comes even more plainly into view this week, with Everton traveling to Old Trafford to take on Manchester United — a club whose current struggles might mean sixth place is their best realistic finishing spot as well.

Before we dig into the match against the Red Devils though, let’s review the joy of the late Crystal Palace win — and what it means to our writers.

Crystal Palace Predictions

Writer First Scorer Everton MOTM Winner Score Points
Writer First Scorer Everton MOTM Winner Score Points
Adam B. Bernard Bernard Everton 1-0 2
Adam D. Richarlison Sigurdsson Everton 2-1 2
Brian F. Richarlison Pickford Draw 1-1 1
Brian L. Richarlison Richarlison Everton 2-0 4
Calvin Richarlison Richarlison Everton 2-0 4
Chris Walcott Walcott Draw 1-1 0
Geno Walcott Walcott Everton 2-1 2
Matt A. Sigurdsson Sigurdsson Everton 2-0 4
Matthew C. Sigurdsson Sigurdsson Everton 2-1 2
Pete Richarlison Richarlison Everton 3-1 2
Rachel Richarlison Bernard Everton 1-0 2
Sean Richarlison Sigurdsson Everton 2-0 4
Tom Richarlison Bernard Everton 3-0 2
Zach Richarlison Richarlison Everton 3-1 2

Predictably, no one had Dominic Calvert-Lewin opening the scoring, since we all (correctly) assumed he wouldn’t start the match. Jordan Pickford’s penalty save handed him man of the match honors, earning a point for Brian F. in that column.

12 of 14 writers had Everton winning the match, with another four correctly predicting the 2-0 scoreline — Rachel and I both silently cursed when Cenk Tosun scored late to move the scoreline from 1-0.

The big week for many of our writers means we’ve got an increasingly tight race atop the table.

Prediction League Table

Writer Points
Writer Points
Calvin 64
Rachel 56
Adam B. 53
Sean 51
Geno 51
Chris 51
Matt A. 51
Pete 50
Brian L. 49
Tom 49
Matthew C. 46
Brian F. 45
Zach 44

Brian L. caught me atop the table, with Pete, Brian F., and Calvin all well within striking distance. With nearly a quarter of the season gone, Geno, Rachel, and Zach might need to get going sooner rather than later to remain relevant as the season moves forward.

They’ll have a chance to start closing that gap this week when Everton plays Manchester United. Jose Mourinho’s club is facing a host of issues right now, but the Toffees have been dreadful away to big clubs over the last decade — so which do we think will win out?

Manchester United Predictions

Writer First Scorer Everton MOTM Winner Score Points
Writer First Scorer Everton MOTM Winner Score Points
Adam B. Sigurdsson Sigurdsson Draw 1-1 0
Adam D. Lukaku Gomes United 2-1 4
Brian F. Lukaku Richarlison United 2-1 4
Brian L. Tosun Sigurdsson Draw 1-1 0
Calvin Lingard Pickford United 2-1 5
Chris Martial Richarlison United 2-1 4
Geno Lukaku Sigurdsson United 2-1 4
Matt A. Lukaku Gueye United 2-1 4
Matthew C. Richarlison Sigurdsson Everton 2-1 0
Pete Richarlison Richarlison Everton 2-1 0
Rachel Lukaku Gomes United 2-0 2
Sean Lukaku Gueye United 2-2 2
Tom Bernard Bernard Everton 2-1 0
Zach None Pickford Draw 0-0 1

There is some optimism heading into this one, but the majority of our writers still think United ultimately wins the match. Interestingly, all but one of the predicted scorelines has the match decided by one goal or less, so we at least believe that the Toffees should be quite competitive.

The most popular pick for scoring the opener is Romelu Lukaku, which...well...of course he is. What could be more Everton that watching a former player single-handedly extinguish an Everton hot streak?

The man of the match votes are pretty widely scattered, though. Gylfi Sigurdsson, Andre Gomes, Richarlison, Jordan Pickford, and Andre Gomes all picked up multiple votes. Tom is the lone writer to go outside that box, picking Bernard to take the honor.