clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Toffees Wednesday Mailbag

New, comments

Answering all of your relevant, and irreverent, Everton questions

The 2016-2017 campaign is starting to come to an end (there are only five more matches!) and the major questions facing the Toffees heading into the summer are starting to come into view.

From: “What should we do with Lukaku?”, to “Which centerback(s) should stay?”, the Everton front office face the most pivotal summer in recent memory.

If Walsh, Koeman, Moshiri and the rest of the board are to meet fans burgeoning expectations they are going to have a nearly perfect summer window.

The biggest domino to fall is certainly the fate of Romelu Lukaku, but you could argue that it is the defensive signings that hold the key to future success, and that is where I want to focus.

If the Toffees bring in a pair of successful young center backs, as well as a full-back or two, then they’d be stationed for short AND long term success in the back and in the midfield, following a stellar past two windows addressing the center of the park.

Ok.....REALLY STELLAR!

Schneiderlin, Gueye, Tom Davies and crew have propelled the Blues into the upper most echelons of Premier League engine rooms with both age and contract situations leaning HEAVILY in the Toffees favor.

While the back line is not barren, Baines is getting up in age, Jags and Williams ARE old (especially for center backs), and no one knows what to expect from Coleman when he returns.

Those are all KNOWN entities though, and while their futures are certainly of interest and importance, they are also short, at least as far as their Everton careers go.

What is going to determine the club’s approach to rearranging in the back line will be greatly dependent upon the development of the younger defenders.

Mason Holgate has certainly shown promise and ability, though I do wonder about his best long-term position. Is he a better right back than center back? If so, is his ceiling at right back high enough for our ambitions?

Matthew Pennington, Brendan Galloway and others, on the other hand, will have to prove to Koeman that they can make the same transition from the youth squads to the senior team that Tom Davies did so well this season.

If Koeman develops an innate trust in some (or all) of these players the Toffees decision-makers will be able to emphasize quality over quantity in the back, a trait they have shown a knack for in their first two windows.

If the youngsters can’t pull a Davies, the Toffees are going to be in the market for a number of defenders to bring into the squad, not a preferred approach for Koeman and Co.

A back line is built on trust and relationships, meaning Jags and/or Williams will still be around in August, but in order to reach new heights the Toffees either need some young players to step up or will spend the summer searching high and low for quality defenders.

Let’s see what happens!

Now to your questions!


After a week of taking both literal and proverbial shots , Ross Barkley definitely came into the Burnley match with a chip on his shoulder.

Everton fans, keenly aware of the knifes edge upon which his future is balanced, showed Ross all the love they could.

With speculation about his future at the club (or not at the club) running rampant, Barkley’s response was going to be read into one way or another.

Come out tense, nervous or lacking confidence and the murmurs of it being time to leave Goodison Park would only grow louder.

Show up with steely resolve, play with passion, dominate the match and Toffees fans would take a breath knowing his Merseyside passions run as deep as ever.

Luckily for Everton supporters, Ross went with the latter and former.

Boy did he ever.

Taking up his now standard right wing role, Barkley simply took over the match.

From his passing to his defensive work, Everton’s diamond made sure supporters know where his heart truly lies.

By the time he scored (who cares if they rescinded it) all Ross wanted to do was share it with his fans, who DEFINITELY noticed.

Everton v Burnley - Premier League Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images

Even the mayor got involved!

So after the love he showed the Goodison faithful Saturday in both his demeanor and his performance, and the knowledge that he is in BY FAR the best, most consistent form of his career, I think his future can be summed up in this tweet.

Finally, Ronald Koeman is many things, but dumb is not one of them.

I think Ross is going to re-sign and is in for the long haul.


Bramley-Moore as home

On the banks of the Mersey

Let the titles flow


As promised last week, I am going to now identify each team’s spirit animal, along with a one sentence explanation as to why I chose that animal.

My guidelines are simple: what animal best represents the emotional and physical traits of any given team.

That’s it.

This week I will cover the bottom half of the table. Make sure to stay tuned for next week’s conclusion to PREMIER LEAGUE SPIRIT ANIMALS!

So without further ado...